Do urban gardens lead to gentrification?

A wide-scale look at Detroit's urban gardens finds that while they don't seem to foreshadow gentrification in the city, there are some unsettling trends about where they're located and the sociodemographics in those areas. For example, home and community gardens are more frequently planted in non-Black neighborhoods, according to the study forthcoming in the journal Landscape and Urban Planning. The study used remote sensing to map 478 home gardens and 130 community gardens across 56 neighborhoods where 700,000 people live in Detroit, an emblematic legacy city undergoing significant redevelopment.

Jason Hawes, a doctoral student at the University of Michigan School for Environment and Sustainability said, we found in the case of community gardens, that the folks who had access to those gardens were wealthier, more educated, and of a higher socioeconomic status. They also tended to be clustered in non-Black neighborhoods. That's a really big deal in a city that's 78% Black.

Study senior author Joshua Newell, an urban geographer at U-M's School for Environment and Sustainability, collaborated with Hawes and Dimitrios Gounaridis, a postdoctoral researcher on the study.

Newell said, our mapping effort produced one of the first city-scale datasets of urban agriculture available in the United States. The researchers incorporated Google Street View along with remote sensing to map the home and community gardens.

The study found that community gardens are in neighborhoods with younger, affluent, well-educated residents, and home gardens are more frequent in areas that are in renewal. And unlike in other cities they compared, researchers found no correlation between urban gardening and potential gentrification. When economically distressed neighborhoods see new parks, rain gardens, and urban gardens pop up, it's typically a sign of gentrification on the horizon.

Hawes said, detroit is the poster child for urban agriculture. The city has been called the next great frontier for urban agriculturalists that narrative brings a unique demographic to town. That demographic is educated with high income or with lower income paired with relatively high social capital. But they aren't necessarily displacing existing residents because there's so much housing available in Detroit.

Hawes said, but you are changing the patterns of access in the city when you expand these practices that spread beyond Black neighborhoods.

This indicates that the practice of gardening may be spreading beyond the Black-led institutions like churches and nonprofits that originally promoted it. This could have implications for Detroit's food scene broadly, as modeling also indicated that gardens are in areas with limited access to fresh produce and are consistently more prevalent in neighborhoods that have stabilized after experiencing high rates of vacancy, foreclosure, and housing demolition.

Gounaridis said, while Detroit's experience was compared with several other U.S. cities, the Motor City emerged as a city of its own unique case city. Maybe in the future, gardens will be more associated with gentrified neighborhoods. But we don't necessarily know if gardens are causing this gentrification or if other factors are the cause.

Journal Information: Jason K Hawes et al, Does urban agriculture lead to gentrification?, Landscape and Urban Planning (2022). DOI: 10.1016/j.landurbplan.2022.104447